When I began The Whittling Post back in 2010, I moved over all culture discussion posts from a now-deleted journal called “It’s Late in the Day”, mainly in order to pad-out my new writing enterprise. The rest of It’s Late in the Day’s posts were merged into The Salad of Convenience, which I have recently started updating again. Curiously, it’s now becoming clear that I missed some posts during the initial migration stage.
And so we come to this.
The below 17-year-old article cropped up in my stats completely at random, and I genuinely have no memory of writing it whatsoever. I was just going to ignore it, assuming the article would be very short and sweet, but it actually looked like it had been quite the undertaking. So, I’ve given it a jolly good grammar and punctuation polish, as I didn’t seem to know what those things were back then, and am reposting it here and now for your mild pleasure.
The story of Dayton, Ohio band Guided by Voices has changed considerably since the original version of my post was written, so some details are now out of date. I’ve tried not to mess with that issue too much, as it might interfere with the heart of what 29-year-old me was trying to say.
Please bear this in mind, should you feel inclined to read any further.
Collected thoughts on Guided by Voices
Sheffield, South Yorkshire
2009
I’m obsessed with GBV now.
I can’t work out whether it’s the vocals, the melodies, the lo-fi production, or the energy and spirit that leaks out of every single song.
I love the confidence they have to just put out everything. One particular track, consisting solely of a discarded bass line, has even made it onto a rarities compilation. This serves as a prime example of the band’s willingness to share. It’s a pretty brave attitude to have, as some may accuse this behaviour as being akin to “scraping the barrel”. I personally could never rate one of their songs, like I would with another artist, as GBV seem to defy criticism altogether. Part of the aesthetic and art of what they do is to put you on a rollercoaster of musical experiments, with the fact that they often fail being also why they succeed.
It’s all part of the experience.
Some of their melodies feel like a throwback to The Beatles or The Who-style simplicity, which is quite endearing. Then they’ll chuck in a disturbing and hypnotic Sonic Youth-style experiment, that throws you off the horse entirely.
I think frontman Robert Pollard has the most perfect rock voice. I could listen to him just reading the phone book, which wouldn’t surprise me if it actually happened. There’s a demo track where you hear him introducing the song, with his smooth Ohio drawl being just so yummy. It’s such a nice moment, as he laments: “I’m not sure what’ll happen with this, but…”, and then cracks on with singing.
Very nice.
I sometimes sit there listening to the band and wonder if it’s all aimless nonsense and I’m a fool for loving it so much. Are they just a drunken pub band who got lucky, or cult geniuses who will never get the mainstream recognition they deserve?
Probably a bit of both.
There’s just so much of it to listen to as well! So many albums. So many rarities collections. So many EPs. So many singles. I’ve been listening to them for two years now, after hearing them on an episode of The IT Crowd, and I’ve still only bought half their output. And I’ve got seven albums and a 4-disc rarities box set (the first of many).
That said, the “classic era” set of constantly-revolving band members dissolved after their ninth album, Under the Bushes Under the Stars, and somewhat rare fanclub-only album Tonics & Twisted Chasers. After these releases, the Guided by Voices brand seemed to lose its grounding, with Bob even having the new line-up go into a “proper” studio with an experienced producer to record Mag Earwhig!.
Sober.
The previous line-up recorded Under the Bushes Under the Stars in professional studios too, but those results still sound a little more pure, retaining the lo-fi edge that makes GBV so interesting. Mag Earwhig! is an eerily well-produced nightmare, with big silences and clean audio tracks. GBV albums are usually full of performance mistakes and atmospheric hissing and the sound of band members stumbling about the place drunk, making Mag Earwhig! a very unsettling listen indeed.
It’s just far too clean shaven for my liking.
I think Bob took the soul of GBV into his solo work when the old line-up said goodbye (or were summarily discarded), so I might follow that output instead. Bob assures us there’s a difference between the two projects, but I can’t hear it. I’ve still got the other Suitcase boxsets to hunt down though, so my journey isn’t over yet.
I’m a geek for it all, but I know one day I’ll pass through it and move on. I am not looking forward to that day.
Do stay in touch, darlings.
Toodles!


