I really could kick my teenage-self for not realising our interest in history while he still had the chance to make a lifelong commitment to it. Instead, he was obsessed with movies, to the point that trying to become a big Hollywood film director/screenwriter seemed like a viable option. Sigh. But, now that I’m in my 40s, I’ve finally figured out what I have a workable interest in. To be fair, what with having an intense psychological aversion to obligation, I probably would have messed-up learning history as a proper educational pursuit anyway. I’m enjoying it now because, well, I don’t have to.
My theory is that I enjoy listening to history audiobooks so much because it makes for great escapism. Not just from the hustle and bustle of modern life, as life has always had a hustle and bustle element to it, but because I’m hearing about a time before I was even born. You know, before things got overly-complicated. It’s entertaining because it doesn’t involve me. Specifically, I’ve found antiquity and prehistory particularly compelling. I suppose it’s similar to why westerners find the east so fascinating, and visa versa: because, relatively speaking, it all appears so different to their own lives. The truth is, of course, that life tens of thousands of years ago was just as much a pain in the arse as it is now, but at least there was more of a threat of you dying a physical death back then, rather than a modern psychological death. That’s what I live in fear of the most: having a complete breakdown due to being cornered by our coldly bureaucratic society.
Physical duress brings people together, mental duress tears them apart.
I first came across Professor Brian Fagan through The Great Courses AKA The Teaching Company, with his series of lectures on human prehistory (although he also covers the first civilisations, rather confusingly). On tape, he sounds like what came out nine months later after Brian Blessed and Simon Callow had a wild night together, which is no bad thing. You’re imagining that union now, aren’t you? Yeah! So much hair. Anyway, this fictitious union has given us a gruff, loud, and beguiling orator, who is often so enthusiastic about his subject that he trips over his own words. It’s actually a little annoying at first, but you forgive him after awhile, once you realise it’s probably more of an age-related thing (he has professional anecdotes that reach back to the 1960s).
It happens to the best of us.
But this review isn’t about Fagan’s lectures, it’s about his written word, which I found myself enjoying very much. You know you’re reading a good book when you find yourself on the last chapter without any time seeming to have passed at all. I mean, I only bought this audiobook last week, thinking I’d dip in and out of it occasionally over a year or so, but I’ve just finished it. Marvellous!
I did wonder, before starting, how one goes about filling a whole book about a people who didn’t build lasting structures or governments or write anything down. A people we only know about through the bones, tools, and cave paintings they left behind. Fagan fills some of the page length/audio runtime with fictional accounts of prehistoric life, which feel somewhat presumptuous at times. These passages are written in present tense, so they read like excerpts of a screenplay. Perhaps Fagan has aspirations, as I once did, to work in Hollywood. Who knows. Still, these moments are meant to bring the prehistoric world to life in your mind, and they do just that!
A good third of the book is actually devoted to Neanderthals, a human side-project living alongside Cro-Magnons that tragically went extinct, and an attempt to dispel the common belief that they were merely club-thumping brutes. While there isn’t a great deal of evidence to the contrary, you can’t help but admire Fagan’s attempts. No doubt, had they survived into the modern age, Neanderthals most certainly would have been enslaved by us, so extinction was probably the best outcome for them.
I found Fagan does repeat himself a few times, which are moments the editor probably should have caught and bundled together. I guess you could argue that he’s restating facts to help the reader/listener remember better, but I think it’s really just sloppiness. This is, however, a ten hour audiobook about people migrating with deer, making tools to kill and butcher the deer, and fashioning clothes out of the deer, so repeating oneself is inevitable and forgivable. His decision to provide conversion rates for weights and measures gets rather tiresome though (just like my “reader/listener” bits here), and often brings the drive of the narrative to a complete halt. We can figure out the amount of kilometres to the mile ourselves, dear boy, so don’t worry!
I was expecting to get bored of the chapters devoted to French cave paintings, but imagining those prehistoric people huddled together in the dark for warmth was actually quite cosy. Plus, as a devoted nerd, it did all remind me of the Mines of Moria to a certain extent. Enough to keep me interested, that is.
While there are no startling revelations within these pages/minutes, you will be made privy to some fun facts, such as sucking the marrow out of a bone being the prehistoric equivalent to popping into the supermarket for a pack of sandwiches; that the eyed needle was invented so far back; and that ambush/bottleneck tactics were as important as weapons for killing large game. It’s just a shame that, in the last chapter, we are reminded that the human race eventually invented work-work, which would obviously lead to junk mail and gas service inspections and 24-hour news coverage.
A bleak end indeed.
I wonder what would have been my skill, had I been born so long ago. I’m as practical as a potted plant and as physical as a glacier, so I’d have probably just sat in a tree waiting to die. One could say that this is pretty much what I’m doing now, only the tree is a block of flats and the frozen tundra South Yorkshire. I guess I could have been a cave painter, but my nyctalopia would have made that pretty difficult. And my claustrophobia. My agoraphobia would have made carving geoglyphs tricky too.
Good grief.
So, yes, if you want to get away from it all by diving into the rich pool of human history, then give Cro-Magnon a whirl in whatever format suits you best! The reader of this audiobook, James Langton, is an endearingly-gentle listen, reminding me of Simon Vance, although his throat does do this annoying clicking/popping thing which, once you notice it, will drive you mad.
I probably shouldn’t have drawn attention to it.
Sorry.
Do stay in touch, darlings.
Toodles!